Search
  • Cory Morris

Withdrawal of Guilty Plea because of DA's failure to advise defense counsel of contaminants on the I


People of the State of New York v. Jonna W. Kull 2012NA023195

The Nassau County District Attorney’s Office waited until after defendant Jonna Kull pled guilty to inform her, as required, that the Intoxilyzer used “had a contaminant on it.” The defendant was charged with DWI and unsafe lane change. Defense counsel originally moved pursuant to CPL 440.10(1)(b),(g) and (h) but the Court considered the application as one to withdraw the defendant’s guilty plea pursuant to CPL 220.60(3).

Defendant pled guilty on June 13, 2013 and the District Attorney waited until December 5, 2013 to inform defendant of outstanding Brady material. The Court found that “[n]otwithstanding this notification from the District Attorney to the defendant’s attorney on December 5, 2013, it is uncontested that a ‘Service Work Order’ had been requested by the police, of the manufacturer, CMI, Inc. on May 1, 2013, some six (6) weeks before the defendant’s guilty plea was entered.

“Clearly, the police department and District Attorney had knowledge of a contamination issue regarding the Intoxilyzer 5000 EN that was used to obtain a BAC of the defendant’s breath prior to the defendant’s guilty plea, and they failed to disclose this information to the defendant. This information, if it had not been improperly withheld from the defendant and her counsel, would have permitted the defendant the opportunity to evaluate the strength of the evidence regarding the reliability of the Intoxilyzer used to obtain the defendant’s BAC, prior to pleading guilty.”

In sum, the Defendant’s motion to withdraw her previously-entered guilty plea is granted.

#bradyviolation #nassaucountydwi #nassaucountydistrictattorneybradyviolation #longislandlawyer #criminaldefense #withdrawalofguiltyplea #dwiplea

15 views

FOLLOW US:

  • Instagram Social Icon
  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Google+ Black Square
  • Twitter Clean
  • LinkedIn Basic Black


Attorney Advertising. This website is designed for general information only. The information presented at this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship.

 

This web site is designed to provide general information only and to help in the choice of appropriate legal counsel. The information contained herein should not be construed as legal advice. Legal jurisdictions differ on major and minor aspects of the law and each legal situation is unique; requiring that all legal situations be addressed with qualified legal counsel. Statutes and case law frequently change; the accuracy of this information can only be represented as of the date of publication.

 

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Submitting or receiving information web does not create an siteattorney client relationship. No attorney clientthis relationship will exist unless you meet with one of our attorneys and sign a retainer agreement. Please do not submit any information that is case specific, personal or confidential. 

RSS Feed
  • LinkedIn App Icon
  • Blogger App Icon
  • Wix Twitter page
  • RSS Social Icon
NADC_logo_200.png